July 31, 2026
1:15 pm

Can I Sell My Sagicor Life USA Universal Life Policy? (2026 Guide)

Universal life is the policy type most frequently reviewed in the life settlement market, and Sagicor’s US block has a specific reason for being full of it. The company Sagicor acquired to enter the American market wrote universal life as one of its core product categories, which means a large share of the older UL policies Sagicor services today were issued under a different name entirely.

This page explains what is happening inside a universal life contract as the insured ages, which documents settle the question, and how to weigh keeping, restructuring, surrendering or selling. Pine Lake Life Solutions is an independent education and consumer-advocacy resource. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting for Sagicor Life Insurance Company, and it does not purchase policies.

In This Article

Your policy may have been issued by American Founders Life
Why universal life behaves differently than you were told
Request these documents from Sagicor
Before you conclude the policy is failing
The transfer step: Sagicor’s change-of-ownership request
Sagicor’s rating position in 2026
Frequently Asked Questions

Can I Sell My Sagicor Life USA Universal Life Policy? (2026 Guide)

Your policy may have been issued by American Founders Life

Sagicor entered the United States by acquisition. In 2005, Sagicor USA, Inc. bought American Founders Life Insurance Company, a Texas insurer operating since 1954, for roughly US$58.0 million in cash, subject to Texas Department of Insurance and antitrust clearance. American Founders Life’s product categories at the time were universal life, term life, mortgage term life and annuities. The company was later renamed Sagicor Life Insurance Company.

So a universal life policy issued in the 1980s or 1990s by American Founders Life is, today, a Sagicor-serviced policy. Nothing about the original contract terms changed because the shares changed hands. What changed is the name on the correspondence and the phone number to call, which is why so many owners of these policies believe their insurer disappeared.

Sagicor Life Insurance Company is Texas-domiciled, NAIC number 60445, with a domiciliary address at 3410 Far West Boulevard, Suite 200, Austin, Texas 78731 and an administrative office at 8660 E. Hartford Drive, Suite 200, Scottsdale, Arizona 85255, according to AM Best’s company profile. Client services: 888-724-4267.

Why universal life behaves differently than you were told

A universal life policy is not a fixed-premium contract. It is an account. Premiums and credited interest go in; monthly cost of insurance charges, administrative charges and rider charges come out. The cost of insurance is calculated on the net amount at risk — broadly, the death benefit minus the account value — at a rate per thousand that rises with the insured’s attained age.

In the early decades, credited interest can outrun those deductions. Later it cannot, and the effect compounds: the per-thousand rate rises with age at the same time the shrinking account value increases the net amount at risk. That is why owners in their late seventies routinely receive notices saying the premium must increase sharply to carry the policy to maturity. It is the design of the contract catching up, not an error.

The consequence for this decision is important. Universal life often has a small cash surrender value alongside a full death benefit. That gap — low guaranteed floor, intact death benefit — is precisely why universal life is the most-settled policy type.

Request these documents from Sagicor

No universal life question can be answered without current carrier documents. Call client services at 888-724-4267 and request the following in writing:

An in-force illustration at guaranteed maximum charges and the guaranteed minimum credited rate, showing the projected lapse year at your current premium. This is the pessimistic case and the one the market prices against.
An in-force illustration at current charges and current credited rates for comparison.
The premium required to carry the policy to maturity on both bases.
The minimum premium to keep coverage in force for the next 12 months.
A policy status letter with account value, cash surrender value, any remaining surrender charge, loan balance and the death benefit option currently in force.

Note the death benefit option. Option A pays a level face amount; Option B pays face plus account value and costs more every month. Switching from B to A is sometimes a legitimate way to cut charges without giving up the policy.

Policy era	Name on the contract	Who services it today
1954 to 2005	American Founders Life Insurance Company	Sagicor Life Insurance Company
2005 acquisition	Acquired by Sagicor USA, Inc. for about US$58.0 million	Sagicor Life Insurance Company
After the rename	Sagicor Life Insurance Company	Sagicor Life Insurance Company
Current new business	Sage product line (term, whole life, IUL)	Sagicor Life Insurance Company

Before you conclude the policy is failing

Several fixes sit inside the contract and cost nothing to investigate:

Reduce the face amount. A lower death benefit means a lower net amount at risk and a lower monthly deduction. Half a policy in force beats a whole policy that lapses.
Check any secondary or no-lapse guarantee. Some universal life forms keep coverage in force regardless of account value if a premium test is satisfied. Ask Sagicor in writing whether yours has one and whether it is currently met.
Repay or reduce a loan. Loans increase the net amount at risk and accelerate the drain.
Ask about accelerated benefit provisions. If the insured’s health has changed materially, an accelerated death benefit feature may release funds without transferring the policy at all.

Only after those are exhausted does the settlement market become the right comparison, and even then eligibility and value are determined case by case and cannot be promised.

The transfer step: Sagicor’s change-of-ownership request

If a sale proceeds, it becomes effective only when Sagicor records the new owner. The company’s guidance identifies the Policy/Annuity Service and Change Request as the form used for a change of ownership, notes that the assignee’s or irrevocable beneficiary’s signature is required where the policy is under assignment or carries an irrevocable beneficiary, and indicates that a completed request is processed in 7 to 10 business days after receipt.

Verify the current form version, signature and notarization requirements, and the correct submission address with client services at 888-724-4267 before signing. Do not stop paying premiums while a transfer is pending, and get written confirmation from the company once the change is recorded.

Sagicor’s rating position in 2026

Per AM Best’s company profile, Sagicor Life Insurance Company carries a Financial Strength Rating of A (Excellent) and a Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating of a (Excellent), both stable outlook, effective July 16, 2026. Those ratings were upgraded from A- and a- as part of a July 2026 AM Best action covering Sagicor Financial Company Ltd. and most of its subsidiaries, including Sagicor Life Inc. and Sagicor General Insurance Inc. in Barbados and ivari in Toronto.

Sagicor also continues to write new US individual life business under its Sage product line, so in-force owners are dealing with an active carrier rather than a closed block at a third-party administrator. Ratings can change; confirm the current one before relying on it.

Frequently Asked Questions

I have a universal life policy from American Founders Life. Who do I call?

Sagicor Life Insurance Company, at 888-724-4267. Sagicor USA, Inc. acquired American Founders Life, a Texas insurer in business since 1954, in 2005 and later renamed it Sagicor Life Insurance Company. Universal life was one of American Founders Life’s main product categories, so a large share of the older UL policies Sagicor services began there. Have the original policy number ready.

Why does Sagicor want more premium than I originally paid?

Universal life deducts monthly cost of insurance charges based on the insured’s attained age and the net amount at risk, and those charges rise steeply in later years. When credited interest and account value can no longer absorb them, the carrier requests additional premium to keep the policy in force. An in-force illustration at guaranteed charges will show exactly when the account is projected to run out.

My cash value is almost nothing. Is the policy still worth reviewing?

Possibly, and universal life is the type where a low account value least reflects market interest. Value in the secondary market is driven by the death benefit, the insured’s life expectancy and the projected premium cost of carrying the policy, not by cash value. That said, no one can promise that a given policy qualifies or what any offer would be. A review establishes the facts first.

What happens if I just stop paying?

The policy enters a grace period and then lapses, and a lapse returns nothing. Before that point, ask Sagicor about reducing the face amount, changing the death benefit option, whether any no-lapse guarantee applies, and whether an accelerated benefit provision is available. A free, no-obligation policy review can put those options side by side. Pine Lake does not purchase policies and has no stake in which one you choose.

Find out what your policy is worth — free, confidential, no obligation.

A 15-minute educational review covers your eligibility, every alternative, and a realistic view of what each path would net you.

Call (305) 209-7183 · Request a review online →

Table of Contents