A life insurance policy is an asset of the protected person, and a Michigan conservator or guardian of the estate generally needs court authorization before selling it — so this is a petition question first and a transaction question second. Fiduciaries who treat it the other way around end up explaining a completed sale to a judge, which is a much harder conversation.
The exposure that follows is equally specific. Your duty to marshal assets and obtain fair value means accepting cash surrender value without documenting what the secondary market would have paid is the omission a successor fiduciary, a remainder beneficiary, or the court will find on review. The cure is a record, built before the disposition, showing that both paths were priced.
Michigan procedure runs through the Estates and Protected Individuals Code; verify the current citations for conservator powers and the required petition before filing. Settlements themselves fall under the viatical settlement provisions of the Insurance Code (historically MCL 500.2077 et seq. — verify), regulated by DIFS. Referrals require one document: the policy cover page, with appropriate authority. Free review, one to two day turnaround, no obligation. Call (305) 209-7183.
In This Article
Authority First: What the Petition Needs to Establish
Before any market test, confirm the scope of your appointment. A guardian of the person generally has no authority over property; a conservator or guardian of the estate does, but sales of assets typically require specific court authorization under Michigan’s probate framework. Letters of authority, any restrictions in the order, and the bond should all be reviewed before you begin.
A petition that gets approved on the first pass usually establishes six things:
- The asset. Carrier, policy number, face amount, policy type, current cash surrender value, and the annual premium required to keep it in force.
- Why the policy no longer serves the protected person. Premiums consuming resources needed for care; a purpose that has expired; a contract projected to lapse.
- The alternatives considered. Retention, reduced paid-up, policy loan, surrender, lapse, and sale — with figures.
- The proposed process. A competitive market test rather than an unsolicited single offer, with independent escrow.
- The intended use of proceeds for the protected person’s care and support.
- Notice to interested persons, including any beneficiaries whose interests are affected.
Many fiduciaries seek authority to obtain and present offers, then return for approval of a specific offer. That two-step approach is slower but produces a cleaner record.
The Fair-Value Record
The standard is not “did the fiduciary get a good price” so much as “can the fiduciary show how the price was determined.” Build the file to answer that:
Document the cash surrender value as of the decision date. Document that the policy was shopped rather than sold to the first caller. Preserve the offers received, the basis for selecting one, the executed purchase agreement, the escrow disbursement record, and the carrier’s confirmation of the ownership change. Where the policy was not sold, document that too — a decision to retain or surrender that was made after a market test is defensible in a way that an unexamined default is not.
For context on the spread you are documenting: federal market data (GAO-10-775) found settlements typically ran roughly 10% to 35% of face value, about four to eight times cash surrender value on average. Our explainer on cash surrender value and the side-by-side on settlement versus surrender frame the comparison a court will expect to see.
Beneficiaries, Notice, and the Objection You Should Expect
Selling the policy extinguishes the beneficiaries’ expectancy. In most cases that expectancy is not a vested property right, but it is exactly what generates objections, and courts take the objection seriously enough that it should be addressed in the petition rather than after.
Two arguments carry weight. First, the protected person’s care comes first; a fiduciary cannot preserve a death benefit at the expense of the ward’s present needs. Second, the realistic alternative is often lapse, which leaves the beneficiaries with nothing — so the comparison is not sale versus benefit, it is sale versus zero.
Where preserving some coverage is possible, a retained-benefit structure can defuse the objection entirely. Ask about it during the review; see how the policy options work.
| Fiduciary Step | What to Establish | Record to Retain |
|---|---|---|
| Confirm authority | Scope of appointment and any restrictions under Michigan’s probate code (verify citations) | Letters of authority; court order |
| Inventory the asset | Carrier, face amount, type, cash surrender value, required premium | Carrier statement; in-force illustration at guaranteed assumptions |
| Consider alternatives | Retain, reduced paid-up, loan, surrender, lapse, sell | Written comparison with figures |
| Petition the court | Why the policy no longer serves the protected person; proposed process | Petition, notice to interested persons, order |
| Test the market | Competitive offers rather than a single unsolicited bid | Offers received and basis for selection |
| Close | Independent escrow; release on carrier confirmation | Purchase agreement; escrow record; ownership change confirmation |
| Account | Gross proceeds, net receipt, application to care | Annual account; disbursement trail; tax documents (IRC Sec. 6050Y) |
| Medicaid context | $2,000 asset limit; $1,500 life insurance face-value disregard (2026 — confirm) | Eligibility file coordination |
Medicaid Interaction for a Protected Person
Many protected persons are on or approaching Michigan long-term care Medicaid through MDHHS. Two figures drive the analysis as of 2026 — confirm both before relying on them. The individual countable-asset limit is $2,000. Life insurance is disregarded only when total face value across all policies is at or under $1,500, so above that threshold the policy’s cash value is already a countable resource.
That means the fiduciary is frequently obligated to deal with the policy regardless; the only question is whether the estate captures surrender value or market value. And because a documented arm’s-length sale is not a transfer for less than fair market value, it does not raise the 60-month look-back problem that transferring the policy to a family member would. See Michigan Medicaid asset and income limits.
Accounting for the Proceeds
Proceeds flow into the conservatorship estate and appear in the annual account like any other receipt. Report the gross amount, the source, and the date, and be ready to show that disbursements were applied to the protected person’s care and support.
Three items reviewers look for. A reconciliation between the offer accepted and the amount actually received, net of any fees. A clear trail from proceeds to expenditures, particularly where a large receipt is followed by a cluster of payments. And documentation of the tax treatment — a sale generates federal tax consequences across a three-tier structure, plus Michigan’s individual income tax on the taxable portion, and a reportable policy sale triggers IRC Sec. 6050Y information reporting. Engage a tax professional for the protected person rather than estimating; life settlement taxes in Michigan outlines the structure.
Diligence on the Counterparty
A fiduciary is judged on process. Before transacting, obtain written confirmation of which states have licensed the provider or broker for settlement activity, verify producer licensing with the Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services, confirm funds are held by an independent escrow agent releasing only on carrier confirmation of the ownership change, and require a specific, revocable HIPAA authorization. Never pay an upfront fee, and never transfer ownership before funds are secured.
Michigan’s framework is summarized in our guide to life settlement regulation in Michigan. Verify the current statutory citation for 2026 rather than relying on any summary.
Educational information for professionals only. Nothing here is legal, tax, or investment advice, and it does not create an attorney-client or advisory relationship. Fiduciaries should rely on their own counsel and on the court’s direction.
How a Referral Works
To find out whether a market test is even worth petitioning for, you send one document: the policy cover page, showing carrier, policy number, face amount, policy type, and issue date — with the authority you hold as fiduciary and consistent with the protected person’s privacy. Redact whatever you prefer.
The review is free, and no obligation attaches to you, the estate, or the protected person. An initial read typically returns in one to two business days, which is often enough to know whether the policy belongs in a petition at all. Where the court will want an indicative range, three further items complete the file: an in-force illustration current as of the request, the most recent carrier statement, and a signed HIPAA authorization. Standard files then take about 60 to 120 days to reach funded escrow, so build the petition calendar around that.
No ownership change occurs until an authorized purchase agreement has been executed and escrow has been funded. Call (305) 209-7183, or review the background material in our Education Center.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can a Michigan guardian or conservator sell a protected person’s life insurance policy?
A life insurance policy is an asset of the protected person, and sales of estate assets generally require court authorization under Michigan’s probate framework. Confirm the scope of your letters of authority and the applicable petition requirements with counsel before any market test begins.
What should the petition include?
The identity and economics of the policy, why it no longer serves the protected person, the alternatives considered with figures, the proposed sale process including a competitive market test and independent escrow, the intended use of proceeds for care, and notice to interested persons including affected beneficiaries.
Is accepting cash surrender value a problem?
Not inherently, but accepting it without documenting what the secondary market would have paid is the omission a court or successor fiduciary is most likely to question. Federal market data shows settlements typically ran about four to eight times surrender value, which is why the comparison should be made and preserved.
What if beneficiaries object to the sale?
Expect it and address it in the petition. The protected person’s present care needs generally come first, and the realistic alternative is often lapse, which leaves beneficiaries with nothing; where feasible, a retained-benefit structure preserving part of the death benefit can resolve the objection.
Does a sale create a Medicaid transfer penalty for the protected person?
A documented arm’s-length sale at fair market value is a conversion of an asset rather than a transfer for less than fair value, unlike a gift or below-value ownership change inside the 60-month look-back. Retain the purchase agreement, escrow record, and evidence that pricing was tested.
How are the proceeds handled in the annual account?
Report the gross proceeds, the source, and the date as a receipt, reconcile to the net amount actually received, and show a clear trail from proceeds to expenditures for the protected person’s care. Retain the tax documents, including any IRC Sec. 6050Y information return.
How do I evaluate the buyer?
Get written confirmation of which states have licensed the provider or broker, verify producer licensing with the Michigan Department of Insurance and Financial Services, insist on an independent escrow that releases only when the carrier confirms the ownership change, and use a specific revocable HIPAA authorization. Never pay upfront fees or transfer ownership before funds are secured.
How long should I allow in the petition calendar?
A standard file runs roughly 60 to 120 days from application to funding, on top of the time required for notice, hearing, and any second approval of a specific offer. Begin the free review early so the petition can be built around a realistic indicative range.
Find out what your policy is worth — free, confidential, no obligation.
A 15-minute educational review covers your eligibility, every alternative, and a realistic view of what each path would net you.
Related Reading
- Life Settlement Vs Surrender
- Cash Surrender Value Life Insurance
- How It Works Policy Options
- Life Settlement Licensing Michigan
- Life Settlement Taxes Michigan
- Michigan Medicaid Asset Income Limits
Pine Lake Life Solutions does not purchase life insurance policies and does not provide legal, tax, or investment advice. Information provided is for educational purposes only. Eligibility for any option, including life settlements, is not guaranteed and depends on individual circumstances, policy terms, underwriting, and market conditions. Consult independent legal, tax, or financial professionals before making decisions regarding a life insurance policy.